Understanding Home Equity and How to Use It

Understanding Home Equity

Home equity is the difference between what your home is worth and what you owe on it — and it’s often your largest pool of low-cost borrowing. You can access equity through a home equity line of credit (HELOC), a home equity loan (HEL), a cash-out refinance, or — for older homeowners — a reverse mortgage. Each option has different moving parts: interest type (variable vs. fixed), closing costs, draw and repayment periods, tax treatment, and risks like line freezes or even foreclosure. Because your house secures the debt, equity borrowing can be cheaper than personal loans or credit cards, but the collateral risk is real; falling behind can ultimately put the home at risk. In 2025 two trends matter most. First, lenders still use risk controls such as combined loan-to-value caps and may freeze or reduce HELOC limits under certain conditions, so don’t assume you can borrow the “leftover” equity. Second, current federal tax rules continue to limit mortgage-interest deductions: HELOC/HEL interest is generally deductible only when the funds are used to buy, build, or substantially improve the property that secures the loan, subject to overall limits. A smart plan starts with a clear purpose (renovation vs. consolidation vs. reserves), then matches the right product instead of chasing the lowest teaser rate. You’ll get a better outcome by understanding how lenders size your line or loan, how variable-rate payments can change, and when a cash-out refi or reverse mortgage makes sense. Below, we explain the main tools in plain English, add two quick-use tables, and include two concrete examples you can copy for your own numbers. If you keep a simple spreadsheet, set calendar reminders for due dates and rate resets, and collect your disclosures in one folder, you’ll remove most of the friction and avoid costly surprises. Finally, the FAQs at the end address deductibility, CLTV math, freezes, conforming limits, and reverse-mortgage spouse protections.

HELOC vs. Home Equity Loan: How They Work (and When to Pick Each)

A HELOC is a revolving credit line secured by your home. During the “draw” period, you can borrow, repay, and borrow again as needs arise; most HELOCs use a variable rate defined as an index plus a margin, so payments can rise if market rates rise. Lenders are also permitted under many plans to reduce or suspend your line in certain circumstances (for example, a significant drop in your home’s value or a material change in your financial condition) — this is a key risk to understand up front. A home equity loan (HEL) is a fixed-rate, lump-sum “second mortgage” with a predictable payment, which many homeowners prefer for a single, known-cost project. The trade-off is that you pay interest on the full amount from day one and you’ll typically have standard closing costs. Which one fits? Use a HELOC when you’ll draw in stages (e.g., multi-phase renovations) or you’re not sure of exact timing; use a HEL when the amount is defined and budgeting simplicity matters more than flexibility. Either way, remember the collateral: missed payments can lead to foreclosure. Read the lender’s Truth-in-Lending disclosures carefully (APR, index + margin, caps, fees, draw and repayment periods) and stress-test your budget for a one- to two-percentage-point rate increase before you sign. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) publishes an official HELOC booklet that explains all of these mechanics — it’s the best baseline read before shopping.

FeatureHELOC (Home Equity Line of Credit)HEL (Home Equity Loan)
How funds workRevolving: draw/repay during draw periodLump sum at closing
InterestUsually variable (index + margin); payment can riseFixed rate; predictable payment
FeesPossible annual/inactivity/early-closure fees; appraisal/titleClosing costs (points/fees); appraisal/title
Line freeze riskPossible reduction/suspension in defined circumstancesNot applicable (closed-end)
Best forStaggered projects or uncertain timingKnown amount; budgeting certainty

Source: CFPB HELOC booklet (variable-rate mechanics, fees, and freeze/reduce scenarios).

Example — Variable payment swing on a HELOC: You’ve drawn $40,000 at Prime + 1.0%. If Prime rises from 8.5% to 9.5%, your rate moves from 9.5% to 10.5%. On interest-only, the monthly payment changes from about $317 to about $350 before any principal paydown — a ~$33 jump for the same balance.

How Lenders Decide “How Much” (LTV, CLTV, and HCLTV — With a Quick Example)

Lenders size equity credit using a set of ratios. LTV (loan-to-value) is your first-mortgage balance divided by your home’s value. CLTV adds any closed-end seconds and the drawn amount of a HELOC. HCLTV (home-equity CLTV) uses the full HELOC credit limit in the numerator — even if you haven’t drawn it yet — whenever a HELOC is present. Agency rules require this treatment so that total potential leverage is measured consistently, and many retail policies cap combined leverage around 80%–85% of value (programs vary). This is why equity access isn’t simply “whatever’s left” after your first mortgage; it’s whatever fits inside the program’s combined cap, your income/debt-to-income, and your credit. Higher combined leverage can mean higher pricing or tighter terms. When a lender quotes a maximum line or loan, ask them to show the exact CLTV/HCLTV math so you can validate it at home. For a sanity check, keep an eye on the denominator too: appraisal values can change the ratios materially, and lenders use the lower of the purchase price or appraised value in some contexts. If you’re near a program cap, a smaller HELOC limit (even if you don’t plan to draw it all) can be the difference between approval and a decline under HCLTV rules. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide spells out how to compute HCLTV, including counting the full HELOC limit in the ratio.

Example — Quick CLTV/HCLTV check: Appraised value = $500,000. First mortgage = $300,000. If your lender caps combined leverage at 80% CLTV, the “room” for seconds is $500,000 × 0.80 − $300,000 = $100,000 (subject to income/credit). If a HELOC with a $120,000 limit is proposed, HCLTV is ($300,000 + $120,000) ÷ $500,000 = 84% — inside an 85% policy but over an 80% policy. That difference can determine approval or required terms.

When Is Interest Tax-Deductible? (The Renovation Rule That Trips People Up)

Under current IRS guidance, interest on HELOCs and HELs is generally deductible only if the borrowed funds are used to buy, build, or substantially improve the home that secures the loan — and only within the broader limits governing mortgage-interest deductions. Using a HELOC to pay off credit cards, buy a car, or fund unrelated expenses typically does not qualify. The most reliable references are IRS Publication 936 and the IRS online FAQs, which give plain-English examples of qualifying versus non-qualifying uses (and note that these rules apply for tax years 2018–2025 under current law). To keep records clean, save invoices and keep a simple spreadsheet tracing each draw to an eligible improvement. If you later refinance or restructure, be aware that tracing rules can matter for what remains deductible. Because tax positions are fact-specific (amounts, dates, uses), talk with a tax pro before assuming a deduction — especially if a line mixed eligible and ineligible uses.

Use of fundsHELOC/HEL interest deductible?Notes
Kitchen remodel / new roof on the same home securing the loanLikely Yes“Buy, build, or substantially improve” the securing home
Paying off credit cards or an auto loanNoNot a qualifying improvement use
Down payment on a different propertyNoImprovements must be to the securing property
Finishing basement with permits on the securing propertyLikely YesKeep invoices/records for tracing

Sources: IRS Publication 936 and IRS FAQs (home-equity interest is deductible only for buy/build/improve uses on the securing home).

Cash-Out Refinance vs. Second Lien: How to Choose in 2025

A cash-out refinance replaces your first mortgage with a new, larger first mortgage and hands you the difference in cash. A second lien (HEL/HELOC) keeps your existing first mortgage and adds a new loan on top. In a higher-rate environment, many homeowners prefer a second lien to preserve a low-rate first mortgage rather than refinancing the whole balance at a higher rate. Conversely, if rates have fallen and you want one fixed payment, a cash-out refi may make sense — but only if the breakeven math and closing costs pencil out. Pricing and underwriting differ because cash-out has a different risk profile than simple rate-and-term refis, so compare total costs head-to-head. Also note that “conforming loan limits” reset annually and influence pricing/eligibility on first-lien refis; for 2025 the baseline one-unit limit is $806,500 (higher in some areas), with loans above that considered “jumbo.” A quick rule of thumb: if your current first-mortgage rate is favorable and your need is finite or project-based, compare a HEL (fixed) or HELOC (flexible) first; if rates improved materially and you value long-term simplicity, run the cash-out breakeven.

Key Risks (and Safeguards) Most Borrowers Miss

Because HELOCs are revolving and variable, monthly payments can rise during the draw or repayment period; stress-test your budget for at least a one- to two-point rate increase before signing. Lenders can freeze or reduce HELOC limits in defined circumstances; read the plan and keep a cash buffer so a sudden limit cut doesn’t derail a project. With any second lien, missed payments can lead to foreclosure even if the first mortgage is current — the second-lien holder still has rights against the collateral. Watch the fee stack: appraisal, title, recording, annual HELOC fees, inactivity fees, and early termination fees can add up; request an itemized list in writing. For taxes, don’t assume “it’s all deductible”: unless funds buy, build, or substantially improve the securing property, interest typically isn’t deductible. Guard against scams such as contractor-steered financing or equity-stripping; shop independently, compare APR (not just the rate), and never sign incomplete forms. A simple safeguard set: get two quotes (e.g., a local credit union and a national lender), read the CFPB booklet, document your intended use of funds, and calendar the end of any intro period so you can adjust early.

Reverse Mortgages (HECM): When Tapping Equity Later in Life Makes Sense

A federally insured Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM) lets homeowners age 62+ convert part of their equity into monthly payments, a line of credit, or a lump sum — without required monthly mortgage payments. You must continue paying taxes, insurance, and maintenance, and the loan comes due when the last borrower (or eligible non-borrowing spouse) dies, sells, or moves out for an extended period. Protections for an eligible non-borrowing spouse have improved and may allow them to remain in the home during a deferral period if HUD criteria are met; however, that spouse does not receive loan proceeds and must keep property charges current. Because fees can be higher than traditional loans and drawing too much too quickly can exhaust available credit, HECMs make most sense for aging in place with a realistic plan for taxes/insurance and maintenance. Before proceeding, complete HUD-approved counseling and read CFPB’s reverse-mortgage guidance so you and your family understand timelines, rights, and obligations.

Shopping Checklist: Compare Apples to Apples

Start by defining the job to be done (renovation vs. consolidation vs. reserves) and a target dollar amount. For HELOCs, compare the index + margin, adjustment caps, draw period, repayment period, and fees (annual, inactivity, early-closure). For HELs, compare APR (not just rate), points, and closing costs. Ask each lender to show your maximum eligible line/loan amount and the CLTV/HCLTV math used to size it so you can validate with your own calculation. If you’re considering cash-out refi, run a breakeven: total closing costs divided by monthly payment savings to estimate how many months until you “earn back” costs — if you won’t stay past breakeven, a second lien may be better. Verify whether any intro rate is temporary and what it resets to; calendar the reset date at signing. Keep documentation on how proceeds will be used, especially for renovations, if you intend to claim the mortgage-interest deduction. Finally, organize your documents — W-2s/1099s, tax returns if needed, homeowner’s insurance, and a list of debts — so underwriting is smooth and quick. If any quote feels opaque, request official disclosures or walk away; transparent lenders won’t hesitate to provide them.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can my HELOC be reduced or frozen after opening?

Yes. Plans generally permit lenders to reduce or suspend a HELOC if your home value falls significantly or your financial condition changes; your agreement outlines the conditions. Read the CFPB booklet section on freezes/reductions before you sign.

How much equity can I usually access?

Policies vary, but many programs limit total combined borrowing to roughly 80%–85% of value, computed using CLTV/HCLTV rules. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide explains when lenders must count the full HELOC limit in HCLTV, which can constrain high limits.

Is HELOC/HEL interest deductible?

Only if funds buy, build, or substantially improve the home that secures the loan, within overall limits. IRS Pub. 936 and IRS FAQs provide the current rules and examples.

Cash-out refi or second lien — which is better right now?

If your existing first-mortgage rate is low, a second lien (HEL/HELOC) often preserves that advantage; if rates drop and you prefer one fixed payment, a cash-out refi can make sense. For 2025, the baseline conforming loan limit is $806,500, which may affect pricing and eligibility.

Sources